New York's theater scene has just rolled out a batch of productions that don't plan to stick around. A murder thriller, a Western musical, a Dickens adaptation and a big-budget magic show are all open now, but several close within weeks — so the calendar matters as much as the cast list.
For thriller fans, the pick is The New Group's Off-Broadway staging of Patrick Hamilton's Rope at Theater at St. Clement's — the same source material that inspired Hitchcock's film. Cameron Monaghan and Corey Fogelmanis play two privileged young men convinced they've pulled off the perfect murder, then invite friends to dinner beside the trunk hiding the evidence. The small theater puts audiences uncomfortably close to the whole charade, which is exactly the point. The run was recently extended by two weeks and now plays through Dec. 20.
On Broadway at the James Earl Jones Theatre, Wanted tells a story most history classes skip. Set in 1893 Texas, the musical follows twin sisters Mary and Martha Clarke, two Black women passing for white as they fight for identity, inheritance and survival in the American West. An ancestral chorus, the Kinfolk, ties their ordeal to generations of family history, backed by gospel harmonies that give the show its biggest punch.
At The Duke on 42nd Street, Copperfield! turns Dickens's sprawling coming-of-age novel into a musical with a clever framing device: David's younger and older selves share the stage, playing memory against adult hindsight. The actor-musician staging keeps things intimate, and it's the shortest-lived of the bunch — closing Dec. 6 after opening in late October.
Families have the best bet of the four with Now You See Me Live at the Al Hirschfeld Theatre. Inspired by the illusion-heavy film franchise, it features four acclaimed performers as the Horsemen, doing large-scale tricks, escapes and plenty of audience participation. At a brisk 90 minutes with no intermission, it's well suited to younger kids. Front-row seats maximize your odds of being pulled onstage, but the whole house gets at least one moment in the act. It runs through Jan. 3.
Anyone planning a New York trip this season can build an evening (or two) around these. Pick Rope if you like psychological edge, Wanted for a big new Broadway voice, Copperfield! for literary flair, and the magic show if the group includes children or anyone who wants to be genuinely fooled. With three of the four closing between early December and early January, booking sooner rather than later is the smart move.