Every driver seems to have one: the car that went wrong in ways that felt personal. New Zealand motoring site Driven has tapped into that feeling with a public poll to crown both a Car of the Decade and a Dud of the Decade, and journalist Damien O'Carroll marked the occasion by writing about his own first car — a 1979 Mazda 626 he's convinced actively despised him.
The car had a lot working against it from the start. It ran on compressed natural gas (CNG), which made it cheap to fill — under $8 — but painfully slow. It wore an unflattering shade of yellow, and its interior came in a colour so unappealing it has reportedly been used worldwide on plain cigarette packaging precisely because people find it off-putting.
What makes the story fun is the pattern of failures. The 626 never broke down on the way somewhere boring; it waited until O'Carroll was close to — but not within walking distance of — a beach, a party or a date, then blew its radiator cap off with a bang and drenched the hot engine in coolant, producing a dramatic steam cloud for bystanders. The window only jumped its runner and jammed in the rain. The fan belt only shrieked when a crowd was watching. A mystery leak made the interior smell like wet dog for a week after every wash, timed neatly before big dates.
This wasn't just teenage ineptitude with a spanner, either. Two replacement radiators plus multiple fan belts and tensioners failed to fix the overheating, and mechanics eventually gave up and suggested trading it in. He did, eventually, for a much cooler 1985 Honda CR-X in two-tone red and silver — but he says he'll never forget the Mazda.
The piece doubles as a prompt for the poll. Readers can vote on Driven's shortlisted finalists for Dud of the Decade and are invited to share their own personal automotive grudges — whether a bad experience with one car soured an entire model or brand. Voters go in the draw to win $2,500 towards fuel or EV charging. The poll taps a distinctly New Zealand vein of motoring nostalgia, with questions raised about the last Holden Commodore being German-built and better than its Australian predecessors, and the final HSV being a four-cylinder diesel ute.
For travellers, it's a reminder of why the car you book abroad matters more than the price on the listing. A cheap, quirky rental can be charming right up until it isn't — so check whether a hire car runs on an unusual fuel type before you commit, budget for the slowness that comes with conversions like CNG, and keep roadside assistance details handy, especially on coastal roads where the nearest town might be beyond walking distance. And if you're heading to New Zealand, the country's enthusiastic car culture and its affection for legendarily bad vehicles is part of the travel experience in itself.