While everyone else books Cape Cod, there's a strong case for pointing your compass further offshore. Aquinnah sits on its own peninsula at the far western end of Martha's Vineyard, an island you can only reach by ferry or plane. It's the smallest of the Vineyard's six towns, but it packs in the island's most photographed sight: the multicoloured clay cliffs and the lighthouse beside them.
The cliffs are the heart of the place. Roughly 100 feet tall, streaked with bands of coloured clay and sand, they've been sacred to the Wampanoag people for centuries — their traditions say the giant Moshup lived here and shaped the surrounding islands. English settlers were so struck by the vivid colours they named the spot Gay Head, the town's former name. The Gay Head (Aquinnah) Lighthouse dates to a first tower in 1799, with the current structure built in 1856, and opens seasonally to visitors. Both landmarks sit inside the Aquinnah Circle Cultural District, where the Aquinnah Cultural Center museum and Indigenous-owned shops make it easy to dig into Wampanoag history.
Then there are the beaches — three of them, each with a different personality. Moshup Beach, a half-mile stretch right below the cliffs, is open to everyone and named for the legendary Wampanoag figure said to have stained the clay red. It's a swimming and skimboarding spot, and anglers come for bluefish and bass. Lobsterville Beach, also public, offers a two-mile shoreline that's good for walking, birdwatching and snorkelling, echoing its past as a lobster fishing ground. Philbin Beach is residents-only, but anyone renting a house in town can get in with the right parking permit or walk-on pass — and its rocky shore and rougher water make it the island's surf pick.
One practical wrinkle: Aquinnah has no hotels. Staying here means renting a home, which sounds limiting but actually unlocks resident-level beach access. It also keeps the town noticeably quieter than Edgartown or Oak Bluffs.
There's a pop-culture footnote, too. Steven Spielberg shot parts of "Jaws" on Martha's Vineyard, and Aquinnah's lighthouse and cliffs appear in the background of some scenes — the famous "Amity Island Welcomes You" sign was temporarily planted here. Film fans can pair a visit with the island's other Jaws locations.
Aquinnah suits travellers who'd rather trade hotel-row bustle for a rental house, uncrowded sand and serious sunsets over the water. It takes a bit more planning than the mainland — ferry or small flight, then a rental — but that friction is exactly what keeps it special. Just remember the cliffs are protected: enjoy them, but leave the clay alone.