On St. Croix's west coast, half a mile south of Frederiksted, a small family-owned hotel has been doing the same thing quietly well since the 1940s: putting guests in colourful, self-contained cottages steps from the sand. It's called Cottages by the Sea, and rates currently start around $269 a night.

The property's backstory is unusual. Harold and Genevieve Benedict bought five acres of beachfront here in 1943 — Harold, a World War I veteran who lost a leg at the Battle of Belleau Wood, needed level, easy access to the sea. His descendants still own and run the hotel today, and the cottages have been updated over the decades without losing their low-key character.

Each cottage has its own name, floor plan and position, and that matters more than at a conventional hotel. Caravelle, for instance, has a king bed, built-in twins, a kitchen and dining area; Martha's Treat offers a queen bed, a galley kitchen and a shaded porch looking at the water. Some units sit right on the beach, others in the garden, so it pays to read descriptions carefully and match the cottage to how you want your mornings to look.

Most accommodations come with full kitchens — a big part of the appeal. Stock the fridge, make coffee on your patio, eat breakfast before your first swim, and keep casual meals in-house while saving dinners for town. There are also shared beachfront patios with barbecue grills, and the west-facing position means sunset is a nightly event right from your chair.

The hotel fronts roughly 500 feet of beach with chairs and umbrellas, and the setup rewards staying put: walk back for a cold drink, grab your book, return to the sand without making an afternoon of it. That said, Frederiksted is close enough for evenings out, with its waterfront, historic buildings and Fort Frederik worth a wander. The Beach Side Cafe at neighbouring Sand Castle on the Beach is right next door when you want dinner without driving.

Practically speaking, the hotel is about eight miles from Henry E. Rohlsen Airport, and a rental car is recommended if you plan to explore beyond town — useful for grocery runs too. Note that parts of the walk into Frederiksted lack sidewalks, so don't count on strolling everywhere. The real advice here is to book around your habits: pick the view, bed configuration and kitchen setup that fit, then stay long enough for the settle-in rhythm to work. This is a hotel for travellers who want a beach house feel rather than a resort programme — unpack, cook, swim, repeat.