Martha's Vineyard has the name recognition, but if you want New England sand, surf and seafood without the summer crowds or the eye-watering room rates, the little-known island of Georgetown in Maine's Midcoast is making a strong case.
Georgetown — originally called Erascohegan by the Abenaki, renamed in 1716 — is a working island community of fishermen, boat builders and artists. It's a classic summer escape for families from nearby states, but it stays pleasant well beyond peak season, and the prices stay reasonable year-round.
The island's beaches are gathered inside Reid State Park, gifted to the state by philanthropist Walter E. Reid, who donated over 700 acres. Geologically it's an oddity for Maine: big dunes and wide sand beaches rather than the region's usual rocky shore. Entry costs just $6 for Maine adults and $8 for everyone else ($2 for seniors). Mile Beach, the largest stretch, has a gentle slope into shallow water that reviewers praise for small children and sandcastle building. There's a sheltered lagoon for kayaking and paddleboarding, with warmer water than the open beaches, plus clamming, frisbee-friendly sand and — according to Tripadvisor reviews — some of the best surfing in Maine. The park has even been rated the top surf spot in New England. If you fancy a second beach day, Popham Beach State Park in Phippsburg is about 45 minutes away with the same entry fees.
Beyond the sand, the Josephine Newman Audubon Sanctuary offers 119 free-to-enter acres with three forested trails: an easy 0.75-mile Horseshoe/Cabin loop past a creek and small waterfall, or the longer 1.25-mile Rocky End Trail through marshes and mud flats. Lighthouse fans are well served too. Perkins Island Lighthouse (23 feet tall, on the Kennebec River) is Georgetown's own, though currently closed to visitors — admire it from a distance. Nearby Squirrel Point Light in Arrowsic is under restoration but free to view from outside, while Doubling Point Lighthouse has a new footbridge leading right up to the tower, with Atlantic views and a decent chance of spotting seals.
The money argument is simple. Georgetown's two main bed and breakfasts — The Mooring (rooms from the low $200s with a full cooked breakfast) and Grey Havens Inn ($200–$395, with the top rates getting you ocean views and a private balcony) — come in well below Martha's Vineyard, where high-season hotels start around $400–$500 a night. Getting there is easy too: Portland International Jetport is roughly an hour south by car.
If you're a traveller who wants classic coastal New England — swimming, hiking, lighthouses, fresh seafood — but balks at Vineyard prices and queues, Georgetown delivers almost all of it at a fraction of the cost, with far fewer people competing for the sand.