You've found the retirement village you love, picked your villa, signed a deal contingent on selling your family home — and then the offers trickle in below asking. It's a common jam, and personal finance specialist Hannah McQueen argues the answer isn't to wait out the market. It's to get better at negotiating the village deal itself.

First, it helps to understand what you're actually buying. In most villages you don't own the unit. You purchase a right to occupy it under an Occupation Right Agreement, and when you leave or pass away, a slice of your original payment is returned. The village keeps the rest as a Deferred Management Fee — think of it as rent paid in advance. On an $800,000 villa with a 30% DMF cap, the estate gets back $560,000 after ten years, which works out to roughly $461 a week for resort-style living. Factor in tied-up capital, weekly fees and inflation erosion, and the maths gets tighter.

Operators rarely drop the headline price — it messes with their pricing across the village — but they have other levers. A lower upfront payment in exchange for a higher deferred fee, cashback, waived weekly fees, moving-cost contributions or a cheaper villa are all on the table. The conversation shouldn't stop at "can you discount it?"

McQueen's core point: your house sale is one lever among four. The others are which villa you choose, the financial terms you negotiate with the operator, and how you invest and structure what's left. If the best realistic offer on your $1.1m home is $900,000, you can absorb that by renegotiating the village side rather than anchoring to a price the market won't deliver. That may mean asking hard questions of your real estate agent — their marketing, their pricing advice — and switching if they're underperforming. Agents often flatter sellers' expectations to win listings; the market doesn't care what you need.

There's a line, though, between making the numbers work and forcing them. Before signing, check when the DMF stops accruing, whether weekly fees continue after you leave, who pays refurbishment, and when your money comes back. Keep accessible savings — emptying every account to get in the door is a bad trade. Independent legal advice on the agreement and proper financial planning on retirement income and future care are non-negotiables.

And the effort is worth it: an Australian Retirement Living Council report found hospitalisations dropped almost 20% in the nine months after residents moved into villages, with residents more active, happier and up to five times more socially engaged. Moving in sooner, on workable terms, beats holding out for a phantom price — or being forced to sell mid-health-crisis with no negotiating power.