After United announced it would block AI bots from its website, one travel writer ran a hands-on experiment: he let an agentic AI — Grok, which drives a real browser — sit down at four US airline sites and try to book the same trip for a family of four. The route: Pittsburgh to Fort Myers, one-way, December 15, 2026. The results were not what he expected.
Delta was the cleanest run. The agent set up the search, added four passengers, compared Basic versus Main Classic fares, clicked past the upsell screens and reached the review-and-pay page at just under $965 — no captcha, no friction, nothing. United, despite its public stance against bots, also let the agent through, though not without a fight: the date picker jumped to 2027 and the passenger selector kept resetting to one adult. It eventually landed on a $964.80 total, exactly matching Delta's price. Southwest produced the best itinerary of all — a 9:50am nonstop at $222 per person, $885.60 total — but the site was the slowest of the four.
American was the outlier, and not in a good way. The agent handled the most complex task of the test, an award booking using the writer's own AAdvantage account, finding a Pittsburgh–Charlotte–Fort Myers routing for 42,000 miles plus $22.40 for all four. It got all the way to the payment page, then hit a wall: the saved card needed a CVV, the checkout session expired, and when the cart was rebuilt, American's bot-detection system served an "I'm not a robot" challenge. A human had to take over. The writer called it a 90% solution — the agent does everything except the final click, which he argues is exactly how it should be.
He also surveyed the airlines' own AI tools. Alaska's "Alaska Inspires," built with Microsoft, lets you type requests like "Where can I go in Europe for under 80k miles?" and claims a 7% conversion rate versus 5% for the standard widget. Breeze uses AI to resolve 37% of service conversations, but that's post-booking help, not new bookings. JetBlue, Allegiant, Sun Country and JSX either offered FAQ bots or blocked the test entirely.
Why does this matter to you? AI agents can already do the tedious part of booking — searching, comparing, dodging upsells — and most US airline sites aren't stopping them, United's rhetoric notwithstanding. The genuine safeguards sit at payment: CVVs, timed sessions and human confirmation. The interesting wrinkle is competitive: if Delta stays the easiest site for an AI to navigate, tech-savvy travellers may simply drift toward it. For now, treat these tools as capable research assistants that hand off to you for the money moment — and think hard before storing your logins in any bot's vault.