Miami has the beaches, the art deco facades, the nightlife, and now — for the third year running — a reputation problem. Multiple 2025 and 2026 surveys have crowned the Magic City the rudest city in the United States, and this time even Miami's own residents agreed.
The most striking numbers come from two studies. Kylian, an AI language-learning platform, surveyed thousands of Americans about local behaviour and gave Miami a 9.88 out of 10 on its rudeness scale — a score it called 'unprecedented'. Residents themselves flagged self-centred behaviour, poor treatment of service staff, and little regard for shared spaces. SolitaireStreak, an online gaming site that polled residents of 40 major cities, scored Miami at 99.29 out of 100, with Las Vegas and Philadelphia trailing behind. Perhaps the telling stat: around 42% of Miamians surveyed said rudeness around them had made them consider moving away. Complaints cited included reckless driving, loudness in communal areas, and near-constant phone fixation.
This isn't a one-off. Preply named Miami America's rudest city in 2024, and Time magazine ran a reader-voted version of the same verdict back in 2017. Local theories range from the blunt — plenty of wealthy, image-conscious residents — to the climatic: one travel blogger suggested the relentless heat simply wears people down.
So should travellers cross Miami off the list? Probably not entirely. Rudeness rankings are subjective, and big-city brusqueness isn't the same as genuine hostility. Miami still offers serious draws: standout hotels, a thriving food scene, excellent nightlife, strong arts, and neighbourhoods like Little Havana and the Design District that carry a distinctly European feel. Plenty of visitors come home with warm stories — it just may take thicker skin than a stroll through, say, Savannah.
The real takeaway is about expectations. If your ideal trip revolves around chatting with locals and feeling embraced by a community, other American cities will serve you better. But if you're coming for the beach, the restaurants and the clubs, Miami delivers — just don't expect small-town warmth from the person next to you at the bar. Busy season crowds and the heat can amplify the edge, so travelling in shoulder months or venturing beyond South Beach can soften the experience considerably.