Day 20 of a John Muir Trail thru-hike was supposed to be a big-mile day. Instead, it became a masterclass in High Sierra weather — and why flexibility beats ambition in the mountains.

The writer woke at Red's Meadow, a rustic resort stop in California's Sierra Nevada with cabins and a restaurant serving hot breakfast, to light overnight rain. It felt like the forecast storm had fizzled. After a civilised plate of eggs, bacon and pancakes, they set off at 8am in a poncho, detouring to the Devil's Postpile — a striking formation of hexagonal basalt columns whose tops fit together like perfectly tiled flagstones. Fellow hikers had given wildly contradictory accounts of how hard the side trip was; it turned out to be a short, worthwhile climb.

Feeling strong and passing younger hikers, the writer eyed a tempting extension: 2.5 extra miles beyond the planned camp at Garnet Lake, up to Thousand Island Lake, banking a head start on the schedule. Big mistake. The weather turned. Rain hardened into a genuine downpour, visibility dropped, the trail dissolved into one long mud puddle, and the wind — funnelled and redirected by the mountains — delivered gusts of at least 50mph that hit like a wall, with the poncho acting as a wet sail.

The day had its human moments. The writer leapfrogged a father-and-three-sons British group finishing a long section hike of the JMT, shared lunch (a high-calorie tamale, a Snickers, jerky) on a lakeshore before the rain returned, and later sheltered near a father and teenage son on the boy's first trip — prime examples of what hikers cheerfully call Type Two fun: miserable in the moment, great stories afterwards.

The real takeaway came from a passing hiker: conditions were worse and more exposed higher up, exactly where the planned camp lay. So the plan changed. A drained tent site in the shelter of the woods, tipped off by that father, beat a cold, wind-battered campsite at Garnet Lake. Pitching a tent in heavy rain — everything soaked within minutes, ground sheet and all — was miserable, but it was the right call.

For anyone planning the John Muir Trail (a 211-mile route through Yosemite, Ansel Adams Wilderness and Kings Canyon, typically walked in three weeks), the lessons are simple: Sierra afternoon storms can arrive with little warning even in summer; download FarOut or a similar app but trust your map too; eat early when a weather window opens; and never treat a schedule as a promise. The mountain decides. Red's Meadow itself makes a forgiving resupply stop — hot food, a bed, and a decent detox of excess M&M weight before the high country.