The Bayesian sinking off Sicily on 19 August 2024 killed six guests and one crew member, including tech entrepreneur Mike Lynch and his 18-year-old daughter Hannah. Now the UK Marine Accident Investigation Branch has published its full 137-page report, and it reaches conclusions that differ sharply from the story being told in Italian courts.

The MAIB's central finding is stark: the 56m Perini Navi yacht had a stability vulnerability that nobody had ever assessed. Its Stability Information Book covered the risk of knockdown under sail only. With no sails set, the centreboard raised and the yacht at anchor — exactly its condition that night — the vessel's windage and stability had never been evaluated. The crew, the report says, were simply unaware of a critical risk to the vessel.

The speed of the disaster is hard to comprehend. The chief inspector, Rob Loder, described calm conditions turning into winds of at least 68 knots within 14 minutes. Once hit, the Bayesian went from a heel of 10-20 degrees to lying flat in under 15 seconds. The MAIB attributes the winds to a violent downburst — effectively a hurricane-force gust descending from a thunderstorm — that no forecast had flagged. No warning was issued for the Lipari Sea that night.

The report also credits the crew who did act: fifteen survivors reached a liferaft, the master and chief officer pulled guests through cascading water to the flying bridge, and two crew members swam back to the capsized hull to try to free a raft. Notably, none of the yacht's liferafts deployed automatically.

The findings collide with separate legal proceedings. Italian prosecutors, whose conclusions were leaked to media, blame "crew error" and characterised the 70-knot winds as "little more than a squall". Three crew members — skipper James Cutfield, chief engineer Tim Parker Eaton and watchkeeper Matthew Griffith — are under investigation in Italy, with no charges filed. Meanwhile the yacht's builder's parent company, The Italian Sea Group, has filed a €456 million claim against owner Angela Bacares, Lynch's widow, and a UK High Court fight is brewing over liability caps for survivor injury claims, with guests alleging the crew left them to "scramble to safety" largely unaided.

For anyone who charters or sails on large yachts, the report is a reminder that stability documentation and weather briefings — the two things crews rely on — can both fail at once. The MAIB doesn't assign blame; the Italian and UK civil cases are still to be heard.