A wave of reports from Marriott employees suggests that some guests are being enrolled in the Bonvoy loyalty programme without ever agreeing to it — and the reason is money and quotas, not service.
According to accounts from front desk staff, some hotels set hard targets of 20 new Bonvoy sign-ups per employee per month. Miss the quota and weekly hours get cut; miss it three months running and, in at least one worker's account, you're terminated for poor performance. The pressure shows. One employee with three years on the desk said they're happy to offer enrolment but is being pushed to keep selling after guests say no. Others admit to shortcuts: a manager enrolling staff work emails, workers repeatedly signing themselves and family members up with different addresses, and one front desk agent saying he treats a guest's acceptance of a welcome bag as consent — and that roughly 90% of his enrolments happen overnight, using emails guests provided for other purposes.
It goes further than fudged numbers. In a separate discussion, a worker said management told them to create accounts first and mention it to the guest afterwards — explicitly framed as a way to remove the guest's chance to say no.
Why the push? Marriott pays for it. A slide from a 2025 owner and franchise webinar shows hotels in the US and Canada earning up to $10,000 a month for strong enrolment performance, with $500–$1,000 'booster' awards for hitting a 20% enrolment success rate. One SpringHill Suites in Maryland collected $20,000 in these incentives in a single year. The company reported more than 295 million Bonvoy members as of June — a number that looks less impressive if a chunk of those accounts were never requested. Loyalty enrolment matters to Marriott commercially: it lets the company market directly to guests who booked through Expedia, nudge where they stay next, and sell its co-branded credit card.
For travellers, the practical takeaway is simple: check whether you actually have a Bonvoy account, especially if you've stayed at a Marriott property recently and don't remember joining. An account you didn't ask for mostly just means marketing emails, but it's worth knowing your details were used. And if you do want the programme, joining at the desk is genuinely worth considering — free night awards, late checkout and lounge access at elite tiers can add up. Just don't feel obliged to say yes because the person checking you in seems oddly insistent.
There's also a fairness issue for staff, who shouldn't have to choose between respecting a guest's 'no' and keeping their hours. A polite 'no thanks, I'm already a member' is usually enough to end it — and per these workers, it's probably true of most guests anyway.
View from the Wing