The turkey gets days of planning — thawing, brining, hours in the oven. But according to a lineup of American chefs, the dishes that actually make or break the Thanksgiving plate are the ones most of us phone in. Their advice, gathered from kitchens across California, Arizona and beyond, is surprisingly practical whether you're cooking at home or booking a resort feast.

Gravy topped the list. Timothy Ralphs, executive chef at The Scottsdale Resort & Spa, argues it's the one sauce that ties the whole meal together, adding moisture and richness to everything else on the plate. Dustin Valette, who runs restaurants in Healdsburg, California, makes the broader point that sauces are where home cooks slack off — and it shows.

Vegetables are the other big blind spot. Eric Klein of Wolfgang Puck Catering says properly roasted seasonal produce with herbs and a splash of acidity is often the best food on the table. Jamie Olivares of Omni San Diego Hotel specifically calls out green beans, which should be cooked al dente and seasoned boldly rather than boiled into oblivion. At Bernardus Lodge in Carmel Valley, chef Gus Trejo roasts carrots whole until caramelized, then blitzes the green tops into a pesto with garlic, olive oil and toasted nuts — a zero-waste trick worth stealing.

Cranberry sauce divides the experts. Chris Knouse of Castle Hot Springs makes his with fresh cranberries and orange juice to cut through the heaviness of the meal. Quentin Garcia of Thompson Palm Springs, meanwhile, unapologetically defends the canned, can-shaped jelly that slides out intact — his point being that its sweetness and acidity simply work.

Beyond the classics, chefs had ideas for everything else: Massimo Falsini in Montecito folds mushroom duxelles and Parmigiano-Reggiano into stuffing for earthy depth; David Nayfeld of Che Fico in San Francisco champions make-ahead deviled eggs as the forgotten appetizer; Jarell Tucker of The Wigwam in Litchfield Park, Arizona insists candied yams should hold their shape under a reduced butter-spice glaze, not drown in syrup. And Pascal Maalouli of Royal Palms Resort in Scottsdale nominates the humble dinner roll — the perfect vehicle for one bite of everything.

Why does this matter for travellers? Many of these tips come from resort and hotel chefs — Scottsdale, Carmel Valley, Palm Springs, San Diego — places that put on serious Thanksgiving spreads if you'd rather eat out than cook. And if you are hosting, the takeaway is simple: shift some of that turkey obsession toward the sides, the sauce and the vegetables. That's where the meal is won.